How to come off the CardSpicy email list — and how to tell which emails will still arrive.
We send one marketing email a month at most: new arrivals, pre-order openings, and buying guides. Every one of them carries a one-click unsubscribe link at the bottom. You never need an account, a password, or a phone call.
The one-click way
- Open any CardSpicy marketing email.
- Scroll to the bottom and click Unsubscribe.
- You will land on a confirmation page. That is the whole process — nothing else is required of you.
The link contains a private token tied to your email address, not your name, and it does not require you to log in. If the link does not work, it is almost always because an email client split it across two lines — copy the whole address into your browser and it will work.
If the link does not work
Reply to any email from us, or write to [email protected], and say you would like to be removed. We remove you manually and reply to confirm. You do not need to explain why, and we do not ask.
What still arrives after you unsubscribe
Unsubscribing stops marketing email. It does not and cannot stop the emails tied to an order you have placed, because those are records of a transaction rather than messages we chose to send:
| Email type | After unsubscribing |
|---|---|
| New arrivals, pre-order openings, buying guides | Stops |
| Order confirmation | Still sent |
| Dispatch confirmation, with tracking and the PSA certification number | Still sent |
| Pre-order progress updates | Still sent |
| Refund confirmations | Still sent |
| Account and password emails, if you have an account | Still sent |
Keeping order email flowing is a legal requirement as well as a practical one: a customer who cannot see their dispatch confirmation has no way to track what they paid for. If you want no email from us at all, place no orders — there is no setting that suppresses a receipt.
What happens to your address
- We stop sending immediately. Unsubscribing takes effect the moment you click, not at the next campaign.
- We do not re-add you. An unsubscribed address stays unsubscribed. If you later subscribe again yourself, that is your choice and it is recorded as a fresh subscription.
- We do not sell or share it. The list is ours and stays ours. Full detail is in the Privacy Policy.
- Orders already placed are unaffected. Unsubscribing changes what we send you, not what we owe you.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need an account to unsubscribe?
No. The link in the email is enough, and it works whether or not you have ever registered on the site.
I unsubscribed but I am still getting email. What now?
Email [email protected]. It is almost always an order-status email rather than marketing — check the table above — but if it is a marketing email, tell us and we will investigate rather than ask you to click again.
Will I lose my $5 join discount by unsubscribing?
Unsubscribing removes you from the marketing list. If you would like to know how it affects a specific order, email us with the order number and we will answer directly.
Can I subscribe again later?
Yes. The join option appears at checkout, and you can also email us and ask to be added back.
Related
Last updated: September 17, 2026